Beyond life: systematic review of frontier zones in digital immortality


Technological advancements offer nowadays opportunities of using deceased users’ data to create websites ou social media pages to homage them, or forwarding those data to heirs. There are also attempts of producing digital immortality - the possibility to use posthumous data to bring the dead "back to life" via chatbots or avatar robots. Such topic has gotten increased attention from the academic community due to the variety of technical, social and cultural perspectives from which this topic can be analyzed. In such a vast scenario, this paper is an attempt to answer the following question: What research topics are being discussed concerning digital immortality in the academic community? We carried out a Systematic Review (SR) comprising papers published in the last 10 years (2011-2021), focusing on digital immortality, derived from studies that address both human and technical aspects of the subject. In the SR protocol, we formulated search strings relating to the topic, and they were inserted in the Google Academic search engine. The articles found were read, tabulated and categorized based on themes they had in common. The results show what points have been more addressed by scholars, and what themes still need to be further explored.


AJ Ibn Abdoulaiye. 1969. Dimensão social e religiosa do Homem no Islão. Revista Portuguesa de Filosofia (1969), 290--300.

Lanfranco Aceti. 2015. Eternally present and eternally absent: The cultural politics of a thanatophobic Internet and its visual representations of artificial existences. Mortality 20, 4 (2015), 319--333.

Alana Soares Albuquerque. 2020. Ser imortal diante do fim do mundo: corpo, ciberutopia e transcendência. Estudos Históricos (Rio de Janeiro) 33 (2020), 133--151.

Paulo Alves. 2018. Qual o preço da imortalidade? Uma reflexão sobre os caminhos adversos da pós-modernidade. OMNIA-Revista Interdisciplinar de Ciências e Artes 8, 1 (2018), 17--23.

Bruno Machado Belisario. 2017. O dualismo corpo-alma e sua influência no cristianismo e na sociedade ocidental. UNITAS-Revista Eletrônica de Teologia e Ciências das Religiões 5, 2 (2017), 886--900.

Gordon Bell and Jim Gray. 2001. Digital immortality. Commun. ACM 44, 3 (2001), 28--31.

E. Britannica. 2017. Encyclopedia Britannica. URL: (Accessed on 02/24/2018) (2017).

Joanna J Bryson. 2012. Internet memory and life after death. Bereavement care 31, 2 (2012), 70--72.

Juliana Cabral, Cristiano Maciel, Vanice Cunha, Jivago Ribeiro, and Daniele Trevisan. 2021. Digital Generation and Posthumous Interaction: A Descriptive Analysis in Social Networks. In 23rd International Conference on Enterprise Information Systems.

Clarissa Carden and Margaret Gibson. 2021. Living on beyond the body: The digital soul of Black Mirror. In The Moral Uncanny in Black Mirror. Springer, 141--152.

Krishma Carreira. 2016. Imortalidade digital: a era dos grandes dados. Anais do Encontro Internacional Tecnologia, Comunicação e Ciência Cognitiva 2, 1 (2016).

Evan Carroll and John Romano. 2010. Your digital afterlife: When Facebook, Flickr and Twitter are your estate, what's your legacy? New Riders.

Daniel Cebo. 2021. Scientific Relevance and Future of Digital Immortality and Virtual Humans. arXiv preprint arXiv:2101.06105 (2021).

Edivandro Carlos Conforto, Daniel Capaldo Amaral, and SL da Silva. 2011. Roteiro para revisão bibliográfica sistemática: aplicação no desenvolvimento de produtos e gerenciamento de projetos. 8° Congresso Brasileiro de Gestão de Desenvolvimento de Produto - CBGDP 2011 (2011).

José Benedito de Almeida Júnior. 2018. Upapitsi: Aspectos da Alma Wauja. Revista Relicário 5, 10 (2018), 116--127.

João de Fernandes Teixeira. 2020. Transhumanism, immortality and the question of longevity. Revista de Filosoia Aurora 32, 55 (2020).

Gabriel Delanne. 1987. A alma é imortal. Edição da Federação Espírita Brasileira FEB (1987).

Luana Brasil Dias. [n.d.]. Morte, Imortalidade e Ciberutopias. ([n. d.]).

Serhii Serhiiovych Dieniezhnikov. 2018. World outlook problems of transhumanism ideas. (2018).

Idoko Vincent Edache. 2021. Cybernetic Immortality and Ecological Imbalance: Insights From African Anthropoholist Physico-Spiritual Ecology. Journal of African Studies and Sustainable Development (2021).

Annelin Eriksen. 2021. The Human Version 2.0: AI, Humanoids, and Immortality. Social Analysis 65, 1 (2021), 70--88.

Miriam Olivia Knopik Ferraz and Ariê Scherreier Ferneda. 2020. A sucessão do direito à imagem e à memória digital: entre a realidade e a metaficção em "Be right back". ANAMORPHOSIS-Revista Internacional de Direito e Literatura 6, 2 (2020), 645--665.

Vanessa Borges Fortes Serapio Ferreira and Miguel Rettenmaier da Silva. [n.d.]. O Pós-Humano em Black Mirror. ([n. d.]).

Radka Fléglová. 2021. Afterlife of digital user data: analysis of evolution of posthumous data policies on social media. (2021).

Masato Fukushima. 2015. Corpus mysticum digitale (mystical body digital)?: on the concept of two bodies in the era of digital technology. Mortality 20, 4 (2015), 303--318.

Vinicius Galvao and Cristiano Maciel. 2020. Reflexões sobre a imortalidade digital em contextos educativos. Communitas 4, 7 (2020), 59--78.

Vinícius Ferreira Galvão and Cristiano Maciel. 2017. The Acceptability of Digital Immortality: Today's Human is Tomorrow's Avatar. In Proceedings of the XVI Brazilian Symposium on Human Factors in Computing Systems. 1--4.

Vinícius Ferreira Galvão, Cristiano Maciel, Ana Cristina Bicharra Garcia, and José Viterbo. 2017. Life beyond the physical body: The possibilities of digital immortality. In 2017 XLIII Latin American Computer Conference (CLEI). IEEE, 1--10.

Vinícius F Galvão, Cristiano Maciel, Roberto Pereira, Isabela Gasparini, and José Viterbo. 2019. Talking about digital immortality: a value-oriented discussion. In Proceedings of the 18th Brazilian Symposium on Human Factors in Computing Systems. 1--8.

Vinicius Ferreira Galvão, Cristiano Maciel, Vinicius Carvalho Pereira, Ana Cristina Bicharra Garcia, Roberto Pereira, and José Viterbo. 2021. Posthumous data at stake: An overview of digital immortality issues. In Proceedings of the XX Brazilian Symposium on Human Factors in Computing Systems. 1--8.

Stefania Graikousi and Maria Sideri. 2020. Death in digital spaces: social practices and narratives. In International Conference on Cultural Informatics, Communication & Media Studies, Vol. 1.

Joshua Hurtado Hurtado. 2021. Towards a postmortal society of virtualised ancestors? The Virtual Deceased Person and the preservation of the social bond. Mortality (2021), 1--16.

Tim Hutchings. 2016. Death, emotion and digital media. Emotions and Religious Dynamics (2016), 191--212.

Jamil Ibrahim Iskandar. 2011. O De anima de Aristóteles e a concepção das faculdades da alma no Kitáb al-Nafs (Livro da Alma, de Anima) de Ibn Sina (Avicena). Trans/Form/Ação 34 (2011), 41--49.

Victor Kaptelinin. 2016. Making the case for an existential perspective in HCI research on mortality and death. In Proceedings of the 2016 CHI Conference Extended Abstracts on Human Factors in Computing Systems. 352--364.

Allan Kardec and Claudio Damasceno Ferreira Junior. 2021. O céu e o inferno. BesouroBox.

Valtteri Kauppi. [n.d.]. The Use of "Uploaded Mind" Personality Constructs for Declarations of Intent Under Finnish Law. ([n. d.]).

Edu Kruz. 2014. Alma E Imortalidade. Clube de Autores.

Kaylee P Kruzan. 2014. New media use in mitigating existential fear. Thanatos 31 (2014), 149--180.

Amanda Lagerkvist. 2017. Digital afterlife agencies and techno-existential closure. Digital memory studies: media pasts in transition (2017).

Vera LC Lamanno-Adamo. 2017. O íntimo, o estranho e o duplo no mundo digital. Ide 39, 63 (2017), 91--97.

Ben Laney. 2019. Bringing the Dead Back to Life: Preparing the Estate for a Post-Mortem Acting Role. Est. Plan. & Cmty. Prop. LJ 12 (2019), 349.

Cristiano Maciel. 2021. Sistemas Gerenciadores de Legado Digital: implicações tecnológicas e legais em redes sociais. In Anais do X Brazilian Workshop on Social Network Analysis and Mining. SBC, 275--286.

Nicolas Matthee. 2019. Studying ritual in contexts of online grief and bereavement: Methodological considerations. Ritual in a Digital Society 27 (2019).

Dirk KF Meijer. 2013. Immortality: Myth or becoming reality. Syntropy Journal 2013b 3 (2013), 166--203.

Kiyoshi Murata and Yohko Orito. 2014. Privacy after death. ETHICOMP 2014--Liberty and Security in an Age of ICTs (2014).

Cayce Myers et al. 2014. Digital immortality vs."The right to be forgotten": A comparison of US and EU laws concerning social media privacy. Revista Română de Comunicare şi Relaţii Publice 16, 3 (2014), 47--60.

Casey Newton. 2016. Speak, memory. The Verge 6 (2016).

Vera B Nikishina, Marina V Sokolskaya, Oksana A Musatova, Irina M Loskutova, Irina V Zapesotskaya, and Oksana Y Bogomolova. 2020. The Phenomenon of" Digital" Death: Formation and Genesis of the Attitude to Death in Social Networks of Students. Cypriot Journal of Educational Sciences 15, 5 (2020), 1262--1275.

Kevser Akyol Oktan and Ahmet Oktan. [n.d.]. Digital Immortality: Transhumanism in the Case of "Altered Carbon". New Approaches in Media and Communication ([n.d.]), 275.

Michelle Ng Perez and Rachel Cohen. 2019. Uploading the Mind: The Basics and Ethics of Whole Brain Emulation. Science In Society Review (2019).

Marcelo Perine. 2004. A herança socrática no conceito cristão de alma. Revista Hypnos 13 (2004).

Platao. Unknown year. Fedão (a imortalidade da alma). URL: (Accessed on 02/24/2018) (Unknown year).

Liran Razinsky. 2020. The Dream of Absolute Memory: On Digital Self-Representation. Lit: Literature Interpretation Theory 31, 2 (2020), 182--201.

Hanson Robotics. 2022. Bina Custom Character Robot. (Acessado em 06/06/2022) (2022).

Martine Rothblatt. 2016. Virtualmente humanos: as promessas e os perigos da imortalidade digital. Jeferson Luiz Camargo (Trad). São Paulo: Cutrix (2016).

Maggi Savin-Baden. 2019. Postdigital Afterlife? Postdigital Science and Education 1, 2 (2019), 303--306.

Maggi Savin-Baden and David Burden. 2019. Digital immortality and virtual humans. Postdigital Science and Education 1, 1 (2019), 87--103.

Maggi Savin-Baden, David Burden, and Helen Taylor. 2017. The ethics and impact of digital immortality. Knowledge Cultures 5, 2 (2017), 178--196.

Carla J Sofka, Allison Gibson, and Danielle R Silberman. 9. Digital immortality or digital death. Postmortal society: Towards a sociology of immortality 173 (9).

Vanda Maria Sousa. 2018. Morde&Assopra-Zariguim e Naomi: o perigo da ausência de uma semiótica da face do robô humanoide. Texto Livre 11, 2 (2018), 264--289.

Johanna Maaria Sumiala et al. 2018. Deconstructing Immortality?: Identity work and the death of David Bowie in Digital Media. A Networked Self and Birth, Life, Death (2018).

Tabea Tietz, Francesca Pichierri, Maria Koutraki, Dara Hallinan, Franziska Boehm, and Harald Sack. 2018. Digital Zombies-the Reanimation of our Digital Selves. In Companion Proceedings of the The Web Conference 2018. 1535--1539.

Jon Truby and Rafael Brown. 2021. Human digital thought clones: the Holy Grail of artificial intelligence for big data. Information & Communications Technology Law 30, 2 (2021), 140--168.

Alexey Turchin. [n.d.]. Multilevel Strategy for Immortality: Plan A-Fighting Aging, Plan B-Cryonics, Plan C-Digital Immortality, Plan D-Big World Immortality. ([n.d.]).

Alexey Turchin. 2018. Digital immortality: Theory and protocol for indirect mind uploading. (2018).

Mariana Luizs Alves Bacurau Ulisses, Alcineia Souza Silva, and Evandro Salvino Diniz Filho. 2019. Era Digital e Privacidade: Um Paradoxo Entre Direito ao Esquecimento e Acesso à Informação. Caderno Verde de Agroecologia e Desenvolvimento Sustentável 9, 2 (2019), 30--30.

Laleska Rigatto Walder. 2019. Be right back-a incidencia do direito no pósmortem e o reflexo obscuro da sociedade digital. Revista Fronteiras Interdisciplinares do Direito 1, 1 (2019), 152--177.

Tony Walter. 2015. Communication media and the dead: From the stone age to Facebook. Mortality 20, 3 (2015), 215--232.
GALVÃO, Vinícius Ferreira; MACIEL, Cristiano; PEREIRA, Vinicius Carvalho. Beyond life: systematic review of frontier zones in digital immortality. In: SIMPÓSIO BRASILEIRO SOBRE FATORES HUMANOS EM SISTEMAS COMPUTACIONAIS (IHC), 21. , 2022, Diamantina. Anais [...]. Porto Alegre: Sociedade Brasileira de Computação, 2022 .